A new Young and the Restless theory is making the rounds online as viewers patiently wait for the debut of Aristotle Dumas, played by Days of Our Lives alum Billy Flynn. Though he won’t make his onscreen debut until June 20, the buzz surrounding his character has been building for six months. With little revealed about who Aristotle really is, fans are convinced he’s more than just another sophisticated newcomer to Genoa City.
One popular theory is that Aristotle is a former Y&R character who disappeared six years ago, now returning with a new identity. Casting Flynn, known for playing Chad DiMera, a very layered and emotional character on Days, only adds more speculation to who Aristotle really is. Viewers are already speculating how his arrival could impact the current storylines and which long-time characters might recognize him. If the theory turns out to be true, Aristotle’s debut could be a major turning point and start some serious drama in Genoa City.
Why Aristotle Dumas Is Such An Intriguing Character In The Young and the Restless
He Is Very Mysterious
According to Us Weekly, it was confirmed that Flynn would be playing the role of Aristotle Dumas in The Young and the Restless, starting June 20. While he has yet to make his official debut, the character is already generating some serious buzz among soap opera fans. There aren’t many details about Aristotle as of now, but that mystery is what makes him so intriguing.
Related
9 Soap Opera Tropes That We Still Can’t Get Enough Of
From the evil twins of Days of Our Lives to the baby swaps of General Hospital, these are the soap opera cliches that we somehow still love to see.
With a name like Aristotle Dumas and an actor like Flynn stepping into the role, fans are expecting someone complicated and may be connected to Genoa City from the past. His presence could shake things up, especially since he’ll likely cross paths with long-time The Young and the Restless characters or bring secrets that have been buried for years. Theories are already circulating that he might not be who he says he is, setting up for a possible dramatic reveal, which is par for the course for a soap opera character reveal.
The Young and the Restless Theory Claims Aristotle Dumas Is Really Cane Ashby
Cane May Have Changed His Identity
Despite Flynn confirming that he will be Aristotle Dumas in The Young and the Restless, there is a chance this could change. As soap opera fans know, characters are known for hiding their true identities or pretending to be someone they’re not. According to Us Weekly, Flynn himself hinted that Aristotle may not be exactly who he seems, which sparked the theory that he’s actually Cane Ashby. Another reason why Aristotle might be Cane is that Flynn compares Aristotle to Jay Gatsby from the novel The Great Gatsby.
As mentioned by Soaps She Knows, Jay Gatsby, whose real name is Jimmy Gatz, had a classic rags-to-riches background, which is very similar to Cane’s. Cane disappeared from Genoa City six years ago, and fans have been waiting for his return since. With Aristotle’s mysterious backstory and Flynn’s cryptic comments, the theory feels more credible. If this is true, it would mark a dramatic twist and a huge comeback for a fan-favorite The Young and the Restless character.
What Aristotle Dumas Possibly Being Cane Ashby Means For The Young and the Restless
This Will Add Major Drama To The Show
If Aristotle Dumas is actually Cane Ashby, it could add major drama to the new era of The Young and the Restless. Cane has been off the grid for six years, leaving behind unfinished storylines with several characters. A return under a new name could mean he has something to hide or something to reveal.
This twist could spark emotional reunions and a lot of tension with the people of Genoa City, especially if Cane’s reasons for returning aren’t pure or if he has an ulterior motive. It would also reintroduce a long-time character in a new and mysterious way, giving long-time fans something to get excited about while adding more drama to current storylines. Whether it’s Aristotle or Cane who is truly returning to The Young and the Restless, Flynn will do a great job of bringing this character to life.
Enjoy ScreenRant’s primetime coverage? Click below to sign up for my weekly Network TV newsletter (make sure to check “Network TV” in your preferences) and get the inside scoop from actors and showrunners on your favorite series.
SIGN UP NOW!
Sources: Us Weekly, Soaps She Knows